My ex-husband’s 20-year-old girlfriend offered to babysit our 7-year-old son for cute “mom-life” Instagram photos

I thought my ex-husband’s girlfriend just wanted a few cute pictures with our son. But two hours after I dropped him off, my ex called in a panic. She was sobbing and my seven-year-old was laughing loudly.

“She wants to babysit me or take pictures of me?” Ben asked.

“Apparently both.”

“Do I get paid?”

“Ask your father.”

My seven-year-old considered this.

“Ask your father.”

“Can I ask for $20? How much do models make?”

“More than your father is going to offer you, my boy.”

Ben grinned.

***

I’ve learned that raising a curious child means answering questions I’d never considered myself.

My ex-husband, Trevor, had been dating Madison for three months.

“How much do models make?”

She was 20, loved Instagram, and had already started calling herself a “bonus mom.”

She’d met Ben twice.

“He’s going to love it,” she told me. “We’ll have the cutest afternoon together!”

“Just remember he’s seven, not a stuffed animal.”

“We’ll have the cutest afternoon together!”

Trevor had asked to keep Ben for two hours while I ran errands.

I didn’t mind Ben getting to know Madison.

But I wanted his father there.

“I’ll be home the whole time,” Trevor promised.

Trevor had asked to keep Ben.

“And you’ll actually spend time with him?”

“Erica, I know how to look after my son.”

I almost reminded him who’d taught Ben to tie his shoelaces last month.

Instead, I grabbed Ben’s backpack.

“You’ll actually spend time with him?”

Before we left, Ben tucked a small toy car into his backpack.

“Are you taking the whole track?” I asked.

“Just the car. Dad said we’d make the turns today.”

Trevor had promised to finish their cardboard racetrack the previous weekend, then canceled because he was busy.

“Are you taking the whole track?”

I hadn’t mentioned it again. Ben had, though.

He’d drawn the missing turns on a scrap of paper and carried it around all week.

“Show him your drawing, baby.”

Ben shook his head.

“He already knows.”

Ben had, though.

That bothered me more than I wanted to admit.

***

When we arrived, Madison had a tripod beside the sofa and matching shirts laid out.

One said “Bonus Mom.”

The other said “My Little Buddy.”

Ben examined his.

“Bonus Mom.”

“Do you have one without writing?”

Madison laughed.

“We’re going to look adorable together!”

Trevor checked his phone.

Madison laughed.

“My mother’s expecting pictures later. She’s excited about us spending more time together.”

I glanced at him.

“Since when?”

“Can we have one nice afternoon without an argument?”

I let it go.

“Since when?”

Madison opened her arms.

“Ben, give me a big hug!”

“Can I take my shoes off first?”

“Of course. Then we’ll do it again for the camera.”

“Ben, give me a big hug!”

Ben looked at me.

“Do hugs need to be on camera?”

I tried not to laugh.

Madison smiled.

“It’s just for fun.”

“Then make sure he has some,” I said.

I tried not to laugh.

***

I’d been married to Trevor for eight years.

He wasn’t a terrible father.

He could make Ben laugh until he got hiccups, and they once spent an entire Saturday building a cardboard castle.

He wasn’t a terrible father.

But Trevor loved the fun parts of parenting.

Everything else usually became my responsibility.

For Ben’s fifth birthday, I’d arranged the food, ordered the cake, and invited everyone.

Trevor carried the cake inside.

Trevor loved the fun parts of parenting.

His mother praised him for organizing such a wonderful party.

He thanked her.

I didn’t correct him.

That was my problem.

I’d complain about Trevor taking credit, then quietly help him do it again.

I didn’t correct him.

Even after our divorce, I reminded him about appointments and suggested activities for his visits.

“What should we do on Saturday?” he’d ask.

“Ask Ben, Trevor.”

“But you know what he likes better than I do.”

I reminded him about appointments.

That morning, I decided to leave him alone.

Ben was safe with his father.

I had errands to finish.

Trevor could manage two hours.

***

Half an hour later, my phone buzzed.

Ben was safe with his father.

Trevor had texted.

“How do you make him smile?”

I replied:

“Try being funny.”

Another message appeared.

“He keeps making faces, Erica.”

“Try being funny.”

I smiled.

“That sounds like Ben.”

Another message appeared.

“Madison needs one normal picture, Erica. This is frustrating.”

“Let him play, Trevor. He’ll smile when he’s having fun.”

Trevor didn’t answer.

“That sounds like Ben.”

***

An hour after I’d dropped Ben off, Madison sent me a photograph.

She was smiling brightly, one arm around him.

Ben looked like he’d been told he couldn’t have dessert.

Trevor wasn’t in the picture.

She was smiling.

“Cute, right?” Madison wrote.

“He looks bored. Give him a break, Madison.”

“We’re almost done!”

I put my phone away.

But something bothered me.

I put my phone away.

Trevor barely remembered to take pictures when he took Ben somewhere exciting.

Why was he suddenly so interested?

***

Exactly two hours after I dropped Ben off, Trevor called.

“Come pick him up right now!”

I stopped beside my car.

Trevor barely remembered.

“What’s wrong?”

“Just come get him, Erica! We’re done here!”

Madison was crying in the background.

Then I heard Ben laughing.

“Is Ben okay?”

“What’s wrong?”

“He’s fine!”

“Then why are you yelling?”

“Madison’s upset. He’s ruined everything!”

“Put Ben on the phone.”

“Erica, please.”

“Then why are you yelling?”

“Trevor, I need to hear my son.”

Then Ben answered.

“Hi, Mom!”

“Are you okay, sweetheart?”

“Yeah! But Dad’s head keeps disappearing.”

“Hi, Mom!”

“What?”

“The camera cuts it off! He looks like he hasn’t got a head!”

Ben burst out laughing again.

Trevor took the phone.

“Are you coming?”

Ben burst out laughing again.

“I’m on my way.”

“And please don’t encourage him and this ridiculous behavior.”

I hung up.

Twenty minutes later, I walked into his house.

***

Ben was sitting on the rug, holding Trevor’s phone.

“I’m on my way.”

“Mom, look!”

He showed me a picture.

Trevor stood beside the sofa, but the camera had cut off everything above his chin.

I pressed my lips together.

“That’s unfortunate.”

“Mom, look!”

“There’s six of them!”

“Ben,” Trevor warned. “Enough of this.”

“What? There are!”

Madison sat on the sofa, wiping her cheeks.

The tripod stood crooked beside the coffee table.

“There’s six of them!”

I crouched beside Ben.

“Did you have fun?”

“Some, I guess.”

“What didn’t you like?”

“The pictures took forever. There wasn’t time for fun or even ice cream.”

“Did you have fun?”

Madison looked up.

“He kept making everything difficult.”

I turned toward her.

“He’s seven, Madison.”

“I understand that.”

“He kept making everything difficult.”

“Then why are you upset with him?”

Trevor interrupted.

“Can we not argue about this, ladies?”

“You called me demanding I collect him. I want to know what happened.”

Madison grabbed her phone.

Trevor interrupted.

“He kept correcting everything I said!”

Ben shrugged.

“Because she kept saying stuff that wasn’t true.”

I looked at him.

“Like what?”

I looked at him.

“She said we do everything together in her video.”

Madison closed her eyes.

“And?”

“We don’t. I do all that stuff with my mom.”

“Ben, sweetheart,” Madison began.

“I do all that stuff with my mom.”

“Can I finish?”

I nodded.

He continued.

“I told her I’d only met her twice before today. Then she started crying.”

Madison stood.

“Can I finish?”

“I was embarrassed. And a bit hurt. There’s a difference!”

“Why?” I asked.

She looked toward Trevor.

He stared at the floor.

I held out my hand.

“I was embarrassed.”

“Show me what you were filming.”

Madison hesitated.

“It’s just a family video. I’m still editing it.”

“Then let me see what you took.”

She unlocked her phone.

“Show me what you were filming.”

The first clip showed her hugging Ben.

Another showed them sitting together.

Then Madison appeared beside him, smiling at the camera.

“Three months into our beautiful blended family, and every day gets better!”

Another showed them sitting together.

Ben interrupted the recording.

“But I wasn’t here yesterday.”

The clip ended.

I looked at Madison.

The clip ended.

“Three months?”

“That’s how long we’ve been dating.”

“You’ve only met Ben twice before today.”

“It’s not meant to be that literal, Erica. Don’t you know how content creation works?”

I read her prepared caption.

“Three months?”

It described their happy family routine, afternoons together, and how rewarding motherhood had become.

“Motherhood?”

“Bonus motherhood,” she corrected.

“Did you ask what Ben wanted to do?”

“Trevor said he loves making videos.”

“Motherhood?”

“Of his toy cars, Madison. Not himself.”

She glanced at Trevor.

“I thought he’d enjoy it. I even bought those shirts.”

“And when he didn’t?”

She looked down.

“Of his toy cars, Madison.”

“I kept trying.”

For the first time, she sounded more hurt than angry.

I could see why she’d wanted the afternoon to work. I still couldn’t excuse making Ben responsible when it didn’t.

Trevor reached for the phone.

“That’s enough, Erica.”

“I kept trying.”

“Ben didn’t ruin anything.”

Madison looked away.

“He could’ve at least tried.”

“He did, Madison. For two hours.”

She had no answer.

“He did, Madison.”

Ben touched my arm.

“Can I get my backpack?”

“Of course, honey. Actually, go play with your cars in the other room.”

Ben headed down the hallway.

Ben touched my arm.

I waited until the door closed.

Then I turned toward Trevor.

“Why didn’t you stop this?”

He sighed.

“Madison was trying to include him.”

I turned toward Trevor.

“You can include someone without making things up.”

“You don’t understand how much time we’ve been spending together.”

I stared at him.

“Trevor, what are you talking about?”

“He comes here. We do things.”

I stared at him.

“His last overnight visit was five weeks ago.”

“It’s hard being a divorced father when every visit turns into a discussion.”

“Then stop making promises you can’t keep.”

Madison interrupted.

“It’s hard being a divorced father.”

“You told me Erica never lets Ben stay long enough.”

I turned toward Trevor.

“Excuse me?”

“That’s not what I said,” Trevor hissed.

Madison frowned.

I turned toward Trevor.

“You said you were trying to get more weekends!”

“I am!”

“I agreed to both visits you requested,” I said.

“Those were the only days I was free!”

“You said you were trying.”

“And you canceled Ben’s visit last weekend.”

“I told you I was busy.”

“You told me. Ben kept his drawing ready.”

Trevor looked away.

“I told you.”

His phone rang.

He glanced at the screen.

“It’s my mom.”

“Didn’t you promise her pictures?”

Madison nodded.

“It’s my mom.”

“She wanted the finished ones this afternoon.”

Trevor answered.

“Hey, Mom.”

I couldn’t hear her first words.

His expression tightened.

Trevor answered.

“Everything’s fine.”

He turned away.

Then his mother’s voice carried through the phone.

“How’s Ben enjoying all those weekends with you?”

Trevor looked straight at me.

“Everything’s fine.”

“Mom, I’ll call later.”

He ended the call.

I held his gaze.

“Why does she think Ben spends most weekends here?”

***

Trevor pocketed his phone.

He ended the call.

“She misunderstood.”

“Then call her back and explain.”

“Erica, leave my mother out of this.”

“She’s already involved. You’re making her wait for pictures of my son with your new girlfriend.”

Madison lowered herself onto the sofa.

“She misunderstood.”

“What did you tell her, Trevor?”

He ignored her.

I took out my phone.

“I’ll ask her myself.”

“You’re seriously going to embarrass me over some photographs?”

“What did you tell her, Trevor?”

I almost put my phone away.

I’d spent years protecting Trevor from awkward conversations.

But Ben had just spent two hours being told to act as if he belonged to a family he barely knew.

I called his mother.

“Erica! Is everything okay?”

I called his mother.

“Yes. I wanted to ask you something.”

Trevor shook his head.

I continued.

“How often do you think Ben stays with Trevor?”

“Well, Trevor said he’s been spending most weekends there lately.”

Trevor shook his head.

I looked at him.

“Did he?”

“Yes. Especially since Madison came along. He told me they’ve been doing so much together.”

Madison covered her mouth.

“Did he?”

“Ben’s only visited Trevor twice this month. He hasn’t stayed overnight in five weeks,” I said.

Silence.

“Then whose weekends has Trevor been telling me about?”

Madison stood.

“What?”

“Ben’s only visited Trevor twice this month.”

Trevor reached for my phone.

“Mom, Erica’s exaggerating!”

“Trevor,” his mother snapped. “Have you been lying to me?”

He stopped.

“Have you been lying to me?”

“Mom, I was trying to show you things were getting better.”

“By telling me something that wasn’t true?”

Trevor rubbed his forehead.

Madison stared at him.

“You told me Erica didn’t want Ben staying here.”

Madison stared at him.

“I said things were complicated.”

“You said you were asking for more time with him!”

He turned toward me.

“Because every time I ask for something, you bring up schedules!”

“That’s how we arrange visits, Trevor.”

He turned toward me.

His mother was still listening.

“Why did you need these pictures so badly?” she asked.

Trevor gave a bitter laugh.

“Because every time we talk, you ask whether I’ve seen Ben.”

“Because I want you to spend time with him.”

Trevor gave a bitter laugh.

“You make me feel like I’m failing him!”

His voice dropped.

“I wanted you to see I was doing something right.”

I looked at the matching shirts.

His voice dropped.

Then at Madison’s unfinished video.

Trevor hadn’t wanted pictures because Ben was enjoying himself.

He wanted proof of a family life he hadn’t built.

His mother finally spoke.

Ben was enjoying himself.

“I’d rather hear about one real afternoon with Ben than see pictures of things that never happened.”

Trevor ended the call.

Madison stepped away from Trevor.

Trevor turned on her.

“You knew I wanted those pictures!”

Madison stepped away.

“Yes. But I didn’t know you were lying to your mother.”

“You knew you were lying to Ben,” I said.

Madison looked at me.

“That’s different.”

“Not to him.”

“You knew you were lying to Ben.”

She lowered her phone.

“I shouldn’t have blamed him.”

Trevor folded his arms.

“So what happens now, Erica?”

I put my phone away.

She lowered her phone.

“You stop using Ben to make yourself look good.”

“He’s my son, too!”

“Then spend time with him. You don’t need an audience.”

Madison picked up her phone.

“I’m deleting the video.”

“He’s my son, too!”

“Seriously?” Trevor asked.

She deleted the draft.

“I’m not using any of those pictures.”

I went to collect Ben.

***

He was sitting beside his backpack, rolling a toy car across the floor.

“Seriously?”

“Ready, sweetheart?”

He nodded.

Then he looked past me.

“Dad, can we finish our cardboard racetrack next time?”

Trevor appeared in the doorway.

“Ready, sweetheart?”

“Sure, buddy.”

“Without pictures?”

Trevor glanced at Madison.

“Without pictures.”

Ben smiled.

“Sure, buddy.”

“Good. You can help me build it instead.”

Trevor reached for his phone to check his calendar.

“Don’t promise him another afternoon just for my benefit,” I said.

Trevor put the phone down.

“You can help me.”

“I’m free on Saturday.”

“Then tell Ben yourself.”

He turned toward our son. For once, I let the two of them make their plans.

***

Outside, I helped him into the car.

“Ben, I’m proud of you.”

“I’m free on Saturday.”

He looked up.

“For what?”

“For telling the truth about Madison. And for speaking up when something didn’t feel right.”

He shrugged.

“She wasn’t trying to be mean.”

“For what?”

“Maybe not. But you can say no to something you don’t like. Even with family.”

“Even if it’s Dad?”

“Even Dad.”

He considered that.

“Even Dad.”

“Good. Because I don’t think that shirt was worth it.”

I laughed.

“Speaking of which, do I still get $20?”

“For what?”

“That was a lot of work.”

I started the engine.

“Do I still get $20?”

“Ask your father.”

Ben grinned.

“I already did.”

“And?”

“He said no.”

Ben leaned back.

“Next time, I’m charging before I put the shirt on.”